[mod] Timbre shim API: move noisy :vargs out of signal data

This is a BREAKING change but only relevant for a TINY minority
of users that:

  1. Are using the `taoensso.telemere.timbre` API shim, AND
  2. Are using the low-level `:vargs` value in signal `:data`

BEFORE this commit:

  The taoensso.telemere.timbre shim API produces signals with
  {:data {:vargs [...]}, ...} with `:vargs` a vector of raw args
  provided by Timbre.

AFTER this commit:

  The taoensso.telemere.timbre shim API produces signals with
  {:kvs {:timbre/vargs [...]}, ...} with `:vargs` a vector of raw
  args provided by Timbre.

  I.e. [:data :vargs] has been moved to [:kvs :timbre/vargs].

Motivation for the change:

  The new behaviour is a more sensible default.

  Basically: anything in `:data` is included by default in output.
  But vargs are generally anyway already in the signal's formatted
  message, so this ends up just creating duplicate output.
This commit is contained in:
Peter Taoussanis 2025-12-03 08:01:23 +01:00
parent 47af80319d
commit cc680b06f5
2 changed files with 16 additions and 15 deletions

View file

@ -35,7 +35,7 @@
(enc/format* pattern vargs)
(enc/str-join " " (map arg-str) vargs)))]
[error msg {:vargs vargs}])
[error msg vargs])
(let [md (if (and (map? v0) (get (meta v0) :meta)) v0 nil)
error (get md :err)
@ -49,7 +49,7 @@
(enc/format* pattern vargs)
(enc/str-join " " (map arg-str) vargs)))]
[error msg (when-not (empty? vargs) {:vargs vargs})])))))
[error msg (when-not (empty? vargs) vargs)])))))
(comment
(parse-vargs true [ "hello %s" "stu"])
@ -63,13 +63,13 @@
[level format-msg? vargs]
(truss/keep-callsite
`(when (impl/signal-allowed? {:kind :log, :level ~level, :id shim-id})
(let [[error# msg# data#] (parse-vargs ~format-msg? ~vargs)]
(let [[error# msg# vargs#] (parse-vargs ~format-msg? ~vargs)]
(tel/log!
{:allow? true
:level ~level
:id shim-id
:error error#
:data data#}
{:allow? true
:level ~level
:id shim-id
:error error#
:timbre/vargs vargs#}
msg#)
nil)))))
@ -208,4 +208,5 @@
:error error
:msg (when msg-type msg)
:timbre/vargs vargs})))})

View file

@ -754,15 +754,15 @@
;;;; Timbre shim
(deftest _timbre-shim
[(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/log :warn "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :warn, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :data {:vargs ["x1" nil "x2"]}, :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/info "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :info, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :data {:vargs ["x1" nil "x2"]}, :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/error "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :error, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :data {:vargs ["x1" nil "x2"]}, :ns string?}))
[(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/log :warn "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :warn, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :timbre/vargs ["x1" nil "x2"], :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/info "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :info, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :timbre/vargs ["x1" nil "x2"], :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/error "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :error, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :timbre/vargs ["x1" nil "x2"], :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/logf :warn "%s %s %s" "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :warn, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :data {:vargs ["x1" nil "x2"]}, :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/infof "%s %s %s" "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :info, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :data {:vargs ["x1" nil "x2"]}, :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/errorf "%s %s %s" "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :error, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :data {:vargs ["x1" nil "x2"]}, :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/logf :warn "%s %s %s" "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :warn, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :timbre/vargs ["x1" nil "x2"], :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/infof "%s %s %s" "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :info, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :timbre/vargs ["x1" nil "x2"], :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/errorf "%s %s %s" "x1" nil "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :error, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "x1 nil x2", :timbre/vargs ["x1" nil "x2"], :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/info ex1 "x1" "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :info, :error ex1, :msg_ "x1 x2", :data {:vargs ["x1" "x2"]}}) "First-arg error")
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/info ex1 "x1" "x2")) {:kind :log, :level :info, :error ex1, :msg_ "x1 x2", :timbre/vargs ["x1" "x2"]}) "First-arg error")
(is (sm? (with-sig (timbre/spy :info "my-name" (+ 1 2))) {:kind :spy, :level :info, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "my-name => 3", :ns string?}))
(is (sm? (tel/with-min-level :debug (with-sig (timbre/spy (+ 1 2)))) {:kind :spy, :level :debug, :id timbre/shim-id, :msg_ "(+ 1 2) => 3", :ns string?}))